The Oceania Times

Top Menu

  • About us
  • Contact Us
  • Cookie Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions

Main Menu

  • Australian Economy
  • Brokers
  • Commodities
  • Currencies
  • Financial Market
  • Gold and Precious Metals
  • Investment
  • Stock Shares
  • About us
  • Contact Us
  • Cookie Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions

logo

The Oceania Times

  • Australian Economy
  • Brokers
  • Commodities
  • Currencies
  • Financial Market
  • Gold and Precious Metals
  • Investment
  • Stock Shares
  • Asian shares fall as investors brace for inflation report

  • A-Mark Precious Metals (NASDAQ:AMRK) vs. Maison Luxe (OTCMKTS:MASN) Head-To-Head Comparison

  • Stock Market LIVE: Indices flat; Nifty below 17,500; IT, Media drag

  • The big change coming to Australian inflation after Reserve Bank governor Philip Lowe laughed at

  • South Korean won, Philippines peso lead losses among subdued Asian currencies

Australian Economy
Home›Australian Economy›Time for Australia to counter Beijing’s cross-border coercion and de-securitise ‘Chinese influence’

Time for Australia to counter Beijing’s cross-border coercion and de-securitise ‘Chinese influence’

By Megan
May 29, 2022
14
0
Share:

Author: Andrew Chubb, Lancaster University

The change of government in Canberra opens the possibility of a thaw in Australia’s diplomatic relations with China. Since 2017, the Australian government has adopted an array of tough China policies on issues ranging from 5G communications to COVID-19. In response, Beijing imposed a diplomatic freeze and since May 2020, informal economic sanctions on Australian exports including barley, coal, beef and wine.

A Chinese flag is seen near surveillance cameras in Beijing, China, 31 March 2022 (Photo: Reuters/Florence Lo).

Substantive Australian policy concessions to Beijing are off the table, but the incoming Labor government has the opportunity to lead Australia’s China policy debate away from its current divisiveness, while getting serious about the still-unaddressed impact of the Chinese government on political liberties within diaspora communities.

The key to resolving this apparent contradiction is to adopt a rights-protection approach focused on strengthening Australia’s democratic rights protection institutions — in contrast to the previous government’s security-centric view centred on a corrosive narrative of subversive ’Chinese influence’.

Among the many recent bones of contention between Australia and China, none were as explosive as foreign interference: ’covert, coercive or corrupting’ involvement in Australian politics and public discourse on behalf of a foreign state. Few in Australia would disagree that activities fitting this pithy ’three Cs’ description ought to be prohibited, with stern penalties attached.

But rather than defining interference in such terms, Australia’s high-profile 2018 legislative response criminalised a far broader sweep of activity, attracting a deluge of objections from legal experts, civil society and academics over its radical expansion of the definition of ’national security’. Critics — many of whom had no connection to China — argued the legislation in effect would outlaw activities ranging from whistleblowing and academic research to peaceful protest.

At the same time, the Espionage and Foreign Interference (EFI) laws have done little to improve the situation of diaspora communities facing coercion by foreign states. This is due to flaws in the legislation, as well as modern communications technologies that make it easier for foreign states to threaten targets from abroad.

The Australian Security Intelligence Organisation (ASIO) has a longstanding interest in countering transnational coercion but has been focused on the potential that targets could be coerced into cooperating with foreign security agencies. Approaching the issue primarily in this way recasts the victims as threat vectors.

The public discussion of ’Chinese influence’ that propelled the EFI legislation through the parliament placed Chinese-Australians in public life under a racialised political microscope. Used as a shorthand for the PRC party-state’s nefarious overseas political activities, ’Chinese influence’ is divisive and ambiguous. The term collapses the distinction between the Chinese community, culture and the PRC party-state, and projects an unwarranted association between the Chinese Communist Party and Chinese-Australians.

Even if users of the term are aware of the nuances, their audiences often are not. Surveys indicate an alarming prevalence of anti-Chinese racism in the community. Not surprisingly, far-right politicians have also increasingly seized upon the ’Chinese influence’ narrative, stoking community division.

The most vivid illustration of the dangerous turn in Australia’s policy discourse was an October 2020 Senate hearing in which three Chinese-Australian witnesses were challenged to ’unconditionally condemn the Chinese Communist Party dictatorship’. No other witnesses — nor any politicians — were subjected to this loyalty test, which then prime minister Scott Morrison himself would not have passed.

The election results suggest not only Chinese-Australians but many others in the community were deeply uncomfortable about these developments. The new government needs to de-securitise the idea of ’Chinese influence’ as a threat to the Australian nation, while addressing the ongoing loopholes that allow foreign governments, including the PRC, to coerce political targets within Australia’s borders.

The new Australian government should establish a Transnational Rights Protection Office within the Australian Human Rights Commission (AHRC). The AHRC is tasked with ensuring the protection of human rights within Australia but has not yet publicly identified the protection of targeted migrant and diaspora communities from political coercion and harassment as a priority.

The new office would serve at least three core functions: provide accessible information and low-risk points of contact from whom individuals facing coercion can seek information, advice and support; data on the prevalence and type of transnational infringements affecting human rights in diaspora communities; and support individuals, communities and families to access legal assistance, humanitarian visas and seek redress.

The enactment of Australia’s long-awaited Magnitsky-style sanctions regime in December 2021 offers a mechanism by which to ensure coercion against people located on Australian territory is not costless for foreign officials.

The new government should make clear that ‘Chinese influence’ is not a threat to Australia’s sovereignty, identity or ’way of life’ and is an overwhelmingly positive feature of contemporary society.

The government can do more to encourage participation from Chinese-Australians, who remain underrepresented in politics. Politicians and public servants should affirm the rights of people of all backgrounds to engage in public life and increase engagement and support for Chinese community groups and organisations. Doing so stands to enhance social cohesion and government-community relations and increase visibility of Chinese-Australians in politics and public life. It would also help reduce the need for candidates from the Chinese diaspora community to rely on support from PRC state-aligned community organisations.

At a glance, de-securitising ‘Chinese influence’ might appear to be equivalent to backing down on foreign interference. But the opposite is true. There are number of legitimate security concerns regarding PRC overseas political activities that ASIO is right to be concerned about. Yet the PRC’s most severe existing impact on politics in Australia — transnational coercion — is yet to be addressed.

Australia’s new government should make clear that the issue of transnational coercion is primarily a matter of rights protection, not security threats emanating from the Chinese diaspora.

Andrew Chubb is British Academy Postdoctoral Fellow at Lancaster University.

Source link

TagsAnthony Albaneseanti-chinese racismAustraliaaustralian electionaustralian human rights commissionaustralian labor partyaustralian politicsaustralian security intelligence organisationChinachinese australiansespionageespionage and foreign interferencefeature-pieceinternational relationsrise of chinascott morrisonsecurity
Previous Article

CION Investment Co. (CION) to Issue Quarterly ...

Next Article

Oil the Driving Force – ShareCafe

0
Shares
  • 0
  • +
  • 0
  • 0
  • 0
  • 0

Megan

Related articles More from author

  • Australian Economy

    Sydney residents assess flood damage as wild weather eases

    July 7, 2022
    By Megan
  • Australian Economy

    Australian Defence Minister to visit India today to boost security ties

    June 20, 2022
    By Megan
  • Australian Economy

    China Mineral Resources Group registered as Beijing tries to cut Australia’s iron ore export prices

    July 21, 2022
    By Megan
  • Australian Economy

    Bilateral Ties With Indonesia Key to Australia’s Economic Goals Says Treasurer

    June 1, 2022
    By Megan
  • Australian Economy

    Economy, energy crisis, Sri Lank border challenge: Anthony Albanese rated after a month as PM  

    June 25, 2022
    By Megan
  • Australian Economy

    How businesses can prepare for the federal election’s market impacts

    July 27, 2022
    By Megan

Leave a reply Cancel reply

You may interested

  • Investment

    Advarra, Leading Provider of Life Sciences R&D Compliance and Technology Solutions, Secures Major Investment from Blackstone and CPP Investments

  • Gold and Precious Metals

    Franco-Nevada Gold Stock: Buy The Dips (NYSE:FNV)

  • Stock Shares

    Insider Selling: UnitedHealth Group Incorporated (NYSE:UNH) CFO Sells 13,183 Shares of Stock

  • LATEST REVIEWS

  • TOP REVIEWS

Timeline

  • August 10, 2022

    Asian shares fall as investors brace for inflation report

  • August 10, 2022

    A-Mark Precious Metals (NASDAQ:AMRK) vs. Maison Luxe (OTCMKTS:MASN) Head-To-Head Comparison

  • August 10, 2022

    Stock Market LIVE: Indices flat; Nifty below 17,500; IT, Media drag

  • August 10, 2022

    The big change coming to Australian inflation after Reserve Bank governor Philip Lowe laughed at

  • August 10, 2022

    South Korean won, Philippines peso lead losses among subdued Asian currencies

Best Reviews

Latest News

Stock Shares

Asian shares fall as investors brace for inflation report

People walk past a screen displaying the Hang Seng stock index outside Hong Kong Exchanges, in Hong Kong, China July 19, 2022. REUTERS/Lam Yik Register now for FREE unlimited access ...
  • A-Mark Precious Metals (NASDAQ:AMRK) vs. Maison Luxe (OTCMKTS:MASN) Head-To-Head Comparison

    By Megan
    August 10, 2022
  • Stock Market LIVE: Indices flat; Nifty below 17,500; IT, Media drag

    By Megan
    August 10, 2022
  • The big change coming to Australian inflation after Reserve Bank governor Philip Lowe laughed at

    By Megan
    August 10, 2022
  • South Korean won, Philippines peso lead losses among subdued Asian currencies

    By Megan
    August 10, 2022
  • Recent

  • Popular

  • Comments

  • Asian shares fall as investors brace for inflation report

    By Megan
    August 10, 2022
  • A-Mark Precious Metals (NASDAQ:AMRK) vs. Maison Luxe (OTCMKTS:MASN) Head-To-Head Comparison

    By Megan
    August 10, 2022
  • Stock Market LIVE: Indices flat; Nifty below 17,500; IT, Media drag

    By Megan
    August 10, 2022
  • The big change coming to Australian inflation after Reserve Bank governor Philip Lowe laughed at

    By Megan
    August 10, 2022
  • Asian shares fall as investors brace for inflation report

    By Megan
    August 10, 2022
  • Australian economy survived Covid better than most but recovery could slow, OECD says | Australian ...

    By Megan
    September 14, 2021
  • The Best Online Brokers, According to 5 Financial Experts

    By Megan
    September 14, 2021
  • Is Disaster Looming for Australia’s Economy?

    By Megan
    September 29, 2021

Trending News

  • Stock Shares

    Asian shares fall as investors brace for inflation report

    People walk past a screen displaying the Hang Seng stock index outside Hong Kong Exchanges, in Hong Kong, China July 19, 2022. REUTERS/Lam Yik Register now for FREE unlimited access ...
  • Gold and Precious Metals

    A-Mark Precious Metals (NASDAQ:AMRK) vs. Maison Luxe (OTCMKTS:MASN) Head-To-Head Comparison

    A-Mark Precious Metals (NASDAQ:AMRK – Get Rating) and Maison Luxe (OTCMKTS:MASN – Get Rating) are both small-cap consumer discretionary companies, but which is the superior business? We will compare the ...
  • Stock Shares

    Stock Market LIVE: Indices flat; Nifty below 17,500; IT, Media drag

    Asian markets started on a negative note following a retreat in Wall Street. This was mostly due to the caution ahead of US inflation data that will shape nvestor expectations ...
  • Australian Economy

    The big change coming to Australian inflation after Reserve Bank governor Philip Lowe laughed at

    How Reserve Bank boss getting LAUGHED at on the world stage will radically change Australia’s economy The Australian Bureau of Statistics is trialing a new monthly inflation data series Reserve ...
  • Currencies

    South Korean won, Philippines peso lead losses among subdued Asian currencies

    BENGALURU (Aug 10): Most Asian currencies were subdued on Wednesday, while most stock markets in the region fell, tracking losses on Wall Street, as investors awaited US inflation data later ...
  • About us
  • Contact Us
  • Cookie Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
© Copyright The Oceania Times. All rights reserved.

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER

Get our latest downloads and information first. Complete the form below to subscribe to our weekly newsletter.